How the CARES Act of 2020 and Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2018 Combined to create a Tax Refund Opportunity for Taxpayers subject to §280E

Ben Condon, CPA

The CARES Act of 2020 provided a five-year carry-back for losses earned in 2018, 2019, or 2020, which allows firms to modify tax returns up to five years prior to offset taxable income from those tax years.

That means a taxpayer could claim refunds from all the way back to 2013 if they generated a loss in 2018, 2014 if 2019 loss, and 2015 if 2020 loss. 

Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2018 added Sec. 471(c) to the Internal Revenue Code in order to simplify accounting for ending inventory for small taxpayers.  

This allows a taxpayer with annual gross receipts less than $25 million to use its own consistently applied books, records and accounting procedures to calculate COGS and to write-off ending inventory completely, potentially unlocking losses for  taxpayers. 

An aggressive, but defensible position a taxpayer could make, would be to make the accounting change to 471(c) and capitalize and run through COGS all or a portion of the cumulative costs that were previously not allowed to be taken due to the taxpayers' inventory method.  

For example, if they were a retailer and forced to use 1.471-3(b) inventory at costs for retailers (see Harborside case) previously, where they could only deduct the vendor price of their inventory as COGS and all other costs were denied, they could make the case to capitalize and run through their 2019 or 2020 COGS many years of now capitalize-able costs through COGS. The rent, security, bud-tender wages, etc. that the taxpayer can now include in their COGS could be retroactively quantified and included in beginning inventory which would then flush through COGS resulting in a large current year tax loss.

This would pull costs that were previously nondeductible into the present taxable loss, which would then be carried back to those years when those costs were disallowed under 280E.

The switch to 471(c) typically requires a Form 3115 - Application for Change in Account method, which must be filed by the extended tax deadline.  There's still time to make this change for tax year 2019 if extended, and plenty of time to plan for this if making the change for tax year 2020.

This is a game changer that could eliminate the historical damage 280E has done to many companies and provide historical tax relief via a windfall refund! 

If you would like to have us review your returns for possible tax savings, please reach out to us at 503-303-3730 or email info@b-cconsulting.com.